Tiny Victories: Keeping a Positive Mindset During Practice Sessions

Tiny Victories: Keeping a Positive Mindset During Practice Sessions


Every so often, it can be useful to step back and evaluate our big-picture trajectories before we zero in on the day-to-day routines that will help us get where we want to be. I came across some wisdom on this topic on The Mental Game of Musical Theatre podcast by Broadway veteran,  professor, and CS contributor David Eggers. There is a lot of outstanding advice in this podcast in the form of interviews with Broadway professionals. I recently listened to an episode with actor, singer, and songwriter Gavin Creel and was struck by the way he describes the importance of seeking small, daily joys—what he calls “tiny victories.” (The two-part episode with Creel is available here and here.).

Essentially, Creel believes that storing up regular tiny victories gives us balance and perspective that allows us to better handle the aspects of life that do not work in our favor. For him, a tiny victory sometimes comes from trimming his hydrangea bushes, or engaging in conversations with the server at his local deli, or committing to regular meditation sessions. By amassing these sorts of small joys, he feels more grounded when challenges arise related to his work (“like walking into that audition room, or weathering that call, ‘I’m sorry, Gavin, it’s not going your way'”) or when faced with one of life’s inescapable, larger disappointments (“those breakups, those losses, those deaths”). As he says,

“Those big, big, big things that seem insurmountable are coming for you, for me, for all of us. If I don’t have a practice in place for me to be able to weather those things, you’ll get through it, but it makes it a lot harder.”

While this is powerful advice for big-picture life events, I think the same philosophy can be applied to small-scale events like vocal practice. When we are practicing difficult material, or working to develop complicated techniques, each practice session has the potential to accumulate “tiny losses” or even (to be a bit dramatic) “tiny tragedies.” Does the world stop spinning if you crack on a high note? Of course not, but it doesn’t feel good when it happens. Incorporating “desirable difficulties” (described here) that take focus and effort to overcome is an important part of meaningful practice. As one of my friends reminded me recently, “Making mistakes is a sign of effort,” and both mistakes and effort are necessary for progress. [Consider revisiting “Failure is the ONLY option“]

So, maybe what our practice sessions need are intentional tiny victories in order to offset the inevitable tiny tragedies that are part of effortful practice. Maybe every practice session needs to include time when you sing something you love just because you love it. Maybe in every session you should stop at some point to recognize, “Hey, that’s something I couldn’t do two years ago!” Maybe when you notice the bad feelings that come along with tiny tragedies, you can say, “I’m feeling frustrated by this because I’m a sensitive person, and being a sensitive person is a big part of what makes me a great artist.”

I would guess that, in some sessions, there may seem to be more tragedies than victories (tiny or otherwise). But, if we follow Creel’s advice and look for more tiny victories to recognize, the balance may swing in a more positive direction.

 

Author’s Note

I wrote this article before Gavin Creel’s untimely death on September 30, 2024, at age 48, from a rare form of cancer. This devastating reality cannot help but add weight and significance to his comments and advice. Creel’s words, shared here, originally aired on The Mental Game of Musical Theatre podcast on September 28, 2023—almost exactly one year before he died and months before his cancer diagnosis in July 2024. Given this new context, his comments feel both prescient and ominous, However, in light of his death, his practice of seeking “tiny victories” to help deal with the “insurmountable” seems appropriately applicable.
Clearly, Creel’s words were not just platitudes. As his Broadway co-star Will Swenson remembers in American Theatre, Creel was “the friend that made every single moment better. Deeper, sillier, more joyful, more absurd, more heightened, more examined, more full of love. It was like he had a constant mantra circling in his head: How can we take this moment and make it fuller?” Swenson also writes, “Broadway mourns the loss of one of its purest, brightest stars. Through his work and his example, he left our art form and our community a better place. A kinder place. A fairer, more equitable place. A far more beautiful place.”
Although Creel’s life was tragically cut short, it is clear that his most meaningful and lasting victories—his impact on others—are anything but tiny.
Rest in peace.
Brian Manternach

Brian Manternach, DM (he/him), is an associate professor at the University of Utah Department of Theatre and a research associate at the Utah Center for Vocology, where he serves on the faculty of the Summer Vocology Institute. He is an associate editor of the Journal of Singing, and his research, reviews, articles, and essays have appeared in numerous voice-related publications. brianmanternach.com / drbrianmanternach.blogspot.com / bmantern@gmail.com